any bedroom
in
Shelter Island
for
any price
11 homes
sort by
map view
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/6
Courtesy of Corcoran
87 N Ferry Rd
House in Shelter Island
studio N/A 1,984 ft²
$2,390,000
Rebate - Find out
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/19
Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
47L S Ferry Road
House in Shelter Island
2 1 732 ft²
$2,195,000
Rebate - $43,900
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/32
Courtesy of Susan C Cincotta REALTOR
1 Sylvan Road
House in Shelter Island Heights
4 3 2,650 ft²
$1,595,000
Rebate - $23,925
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/20
Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
18 Bowditch Road
House in Shelter Island Heights
3 2 1,567 ft²
$875,000
Rebate - $14,375
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/36
Courtesy of Douglas Elliman
24 S Midway Rd
House in Shelter Island Heights
5 5 4,475 ft²
$2,995,000
Rebate - $49,917
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/23
Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
23 Sunnyside Avenue
House in Shelter Island
7 4.5 4,538 ft²
$2,299,000
Rebate - $30,653
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/8
Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
1 S Ferry Rd
House in Shelter Island
5 3 4,872 ft²
$1,450,000
Rebate - $19,333
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/21
Courtesy of Susan C Cincotta REALTOR
90 Peconic Avenue
House in Shelter Island
5 3.5 3,325 ft²
$3,500,000
Rebate - $58,333
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/22
Courtesy of Town And Country
7 Lari Lane
House in Shelter Island Heights
4 4 4,300 ft²
$4,500,000
Rebate - $90,000
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/27
Courtesy of Daniel Gale Sothebys Intl Rlty
7 Dickerson Drive
House in Shelter Island
4 3 2,094 ft²
$1,395,000
Rebate - $27,900
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
Photo of property
1/19
Courtesy of Town And Country
10 Lari Lane
House in Shelter Island Heights
10 9.5 139,392 ft²
$14,500,000
Rebate - Find out