How To Negotiate A Broker Commission When Selling In NYC

A seller and real estate broker are arm wrestling to negotiate the broker commission but the broker has a steel arm and can't lose

If you are selling an apartment in NYC and not negotiating your broker commission, you’re leaving thousands of dollars on the table. While it was easy to believe the (false) claim that your agent was “free” when you bought, there is no sugarcoating it when you sell. Every dollar you pay your agent is a dollar out of your pocket. Learn how to negotiate your broker commission and push back on the tired justifications you’ll certainly hear.

Table of Contents:

How are NYC broker commissions typically structured?
Can you negotiate a NYC broker commission?
How to negotiate a broker commission when selling in NYC
Does a seller need to pay a commission to the buyer’s agent?
Lies agents will use to justify high broker commissions
How to sell with the lowest broker commissions in NYC

How are NYC broker commissions typically structured?

The first step in officially putting your apartment on the market is signing a “listing agreement” with your agent. The listing agreement is essentially a contract that outlines the terms on which you are hiring your agent. Before signing a listing agreement, you should read the entire document carefully.

This is where you'll find the details of the broker commission. Most of the time, it is structured as a flat percentage of the purchase price. Your agent will also agree to split the commission with the buyer’s agent, should they have one. That is a key detail and results in an even more egregious commission with direct buyers. More on that later.

Can you negotiate a NYC broker commission?

Broker commissions are always negotiable. Hard stop.

There is also no “standard” broker commission. 6% is most common but to say it is “standard” across the industry implies price fixing and can get a real estate agent in a lot of trouble.

A 6% broker commission is far from ubiquitous though. It is only slightly more common than 5%.

Everyone is free to charge whatever they want. If someone tells you otherwise, they are lying.


How to negotiate a broker commission when selling in NYC

There are a couple ways you can easily negotiate down your broker commission.

Interview multiple agents

Interviewing multiple agents gives you options and leverage. You’ll also hear different pitches so you can compare each agent’s valuation of your apartment and the terms of their listing agreement.

When an agent knows they are in a competitive situation, they are much more likely to reduce their commission.

Ask your agent why they are worth their broker commission

Most agents justify their commission by saying that’s what they charge. Don’t let them off the hook that easily! Ask why 6% is the right amount. Why not 5% or 1% or 10%? We bet you'll get some interesting answers!

In reality, agents stick to 6% because that’s what they’ve always charged and sellers pay it. With rising property prices, that means agents make 50% more per transaction than they did ten years ago.

Get a real world home valuation in ~2 hours.
Learn more here

Push back on dual agency commissions

Dual agency arises when an unrepresented buyer wants to purchase your property. This is also called a "direct" buyer. In this situation, your agent represents you and the buyer, becoming a “dual agent.”

Remember your broker commission is a flat percentage and then the buyer has an agent, it will be split with them. If the buyer is unrepresented, your agent will go home with the whole thing. Listing agents love direct buyers.

This is arguably the most ridiculous part of most listing agreements. Which do you think is more work and costly for your agent?

  • Find you as a client, take photos, post the listing, host open houses, accommodate private showings, negotiate the offer, etc
  • Put together the buyer’s purchase application

If your agent won’t reduce their commission in a dual agency situation, they’re either extremely slow at paperwork or being greedy.

An easy way to make this point is to ask how long it takes them to put together a board application. Then compare that to the incremental 3% if they’re earning and ask if that seems reasonable. You will find they are easily asking for $1,000 per hour to organize documents.

If they maintain it’s an appropriate commission, tell them you’ll have Yoreevo represent the buyer for 1% (like we do all of our buyers).

Does a seller need to pay a commission to the buyer's agent?

A seller is not required to offer a commission (or "co-broke") to the buyer's agent. However, most brokers will not take your listing if you do not because it makes their job significantly more difficult and will likely result in a lower price.

In NYC, almost all buyer agents are paid a commission by the seller. The commission is advertised online so an agent knows how much they will be paid on each listing.

Very roughly, we would say 90% of NYC buyers have an agent and by not paying those agents, you reduce the size of your buyer pool. In order to mobilize the buyer agent community to sell your listing, almost all sellers offer to pay a commission to the buyer's agent.

Lies agents will use to justify high broker commissions

Yoreevo is a full service real estate brokerage which charges a total commission of 2-4% versus traditional brokerages at 5-6%. We do this by operating more efficiently, particularly in lead generation (like this blog post).

When traditional agents are interviewed against us, there a few common lies they will tell the seller, in hopes they will continue to pay 6%.

“You get what you pay for”

By far, the number one cliché / lie we would love to ban from the mouths of every real estate agent is “you get what you pay for.” It’s easy to see the point they’re trying to make - since you’re paying less, you must be getting less. It’s not true and they've probably never heard of Yoreevo until this point but they’re somehow still sure they're better.

But what if we flipped that around? Would you get more by paying more? Apparently not because a commission over 6% is virtually unheard of. How is it that every real estate agent worth exactly 6%?

Looking at it another way, agents will routinely accept a 5% commission if it will get the seller to sign the listing agreement. But wait - doesn’t that mean you’re only getting 5/6ths of the effort they would otherwise make?

So there’s a cap on broker commissions - you can’t pay more to get more - and paying less only sometimes gets you less. Hmmm...

Your agent won’t be motivated with less than 6%

We recently saw an article on another NYC real estate website explaining why you need to pay 6% to sell. It was essentially a collection of quotes from real estate agents and one in particular caught our attention -

“[Your agent] might only sell two apartments per year, so naturally, they'll pursue - and devote more effort to - the jobs that will pay the best commissions.”

Believe it or not, that datapoint is true. The average NYC real estate agent only does two deals per year. These agents must be exceptionally slow because it doesn’t take six months of full time work to close a transaction.

We can’t quite square this hypothetical agent who will run through walls for your listing but is also content with just two deals per year.

How to sell with the lowest broker commissions in NYC

What’s the best way to negotiate a lower broker commission in NYC? By not negotiating at all!

Yoreevo offers full service listing services for a 1% commission. Your all-in broker commission, including the buyer’s agent, will be 2-4% versus 5-6% with a traditional brokerage.

Agents will make up all kinds of lies to maintain the status quo and honestly we love hearing them. After you talk to an agent who insists 6% is necessary, talk to Yoreevo and we’ll explain how our modern approach can save you a ton of money!

Chart showing commissions from selling with Yoreevo versus a traditional real estate brokerage

Note: There is a $7,500 minimum which applies to properties under $750,000

Similar Articles

Real estate broker with a big magnet sucking up real estate broker commissions in the form of cash
Are NYC Real Estate Broker Commissions Too High?
Read more
Bored real estate agent looking at her phone, hoping it a client will call
How Does Yoreevo's Low Commission Business Model Work?
Read more

Shop for NYC apartments
online and save thousands!

Full service agents and commission rebates up to 2% Get Your Rebate!