Investment Opportunity in Sag Harbor with Water Access. Located on a sunny, quiet street in the beautiful waterfront private community of Sunset Shores is this .54 acre property being offered for the first time in a generation. Keep and renovate the cottage in place, or build the home of your dreams on this perfectly situated corner lot- just a block away from deeded bay access, perfect for paddleboarding or kayaking! Being sold as-is, or as new construction asking $3,495,000. fixer upper.