The listing at 44 St Marys Road has been taken down and no longer for sale.
Here are the listings available in the same neighborhood.
Home
Feed
Location
Shelter Island
Price
Type
Bedrooms
Amenities
Other

19 Shelter Island Condos, Coops or Houses and Apartments

Map View:
Sort By:
House in Shelter Island Heights at 14 Fred's Lane for $2,485,000
14 Fred's Lane
House in Shelter Island at Lake Drive for $3,250,000
28 Lake Drive
House in Shelter Island Heights at 12 Terry Dr. for $2,950,000
12 Terry Dr.
House in Shelter Island Heights at N Brander Parkway for $1,495,000
15 N Brander Parkway
House in Shelter Island at Dickerson Drive for $2,450,000
15 Dickerson Drive
Coop in Shelter Island Heights at 13 Winthrop Road #24 for $499,000
13 Winthrop Road #24
House in Shelter Island Heights at Rocky Point Road for $3,290,000
24 Rocky Point Road
House in Shelter Island Heights at E Brander Parkway for $5,350,000
29 E Brander Parkway
House in Shelter Island Heights at W Neck Road for $1,450,000
45 W Neck Road
House in Shelter Island Heights at Locust Avenue for $1,850,000
7 Locust Avenue
House in Shelter Island Heights at Crescent Way for $1,975,000
17 Crescent Way
House in Shelter Island Heights at 8 Hilo Drive for $3,850,000
8 Hilo Drive
House in Shelter Island Heights at 141A N Ferry Road for $4,250,000
141A N Ferry Road
House in Shelter Island at 73 N Midway Road for $1,845,000
73 N Midway Road
House in Shelter Island at 13 Tarkettle Road for $2,999,000
13 Tarkettle Road
1-15 of 19