EXTRAORDINARY, Not Ordinary! Welcome to 1 & 2 Finnin Place, a rare offering in the charming waterfront community of Bayville. Ideally located between Oyster Bay Harbor and the Long Island Sound, Bayville is known for its scenic beauty, local shops, beaches, parks, and convenient access to nearby villages and New York City. This unique property presents an exceptional opportunity for investment or flexible living arrangements, featuring two separate homes situated on three tax lots. The main residence offers 3 bedrooms and 2 full bathrooms, along with a lower level complete with laundry. The second home is a well-appointed 2-bedroom cottage with an additional office and 1.5 bathrooms, offering versatile use options. Both homes feature private outdoor space, enhancing the overall appeal and functionality of the property. The 3-bedroom home has been thoughtfully updated with a new boiler, roof, siding, and windows. The shared cesspool system services both homes and is less than 5 years old. Located in Flood Zone X, the property is in a lower-risk flood area, and the current homeowners do not carry flood insurance, offering an added layer of cost efficiency. Currently tenant-occupied, this property provides immediate income potential while offering flexibility for future use or expansion possibilities (subject to local zoning and permits). Located close to beaches, parks, dining, and nearby North Shore villages, this is a rare opportunity to own a multi-structure property with added land value in one of Long Island's most desirable coastal communities.